Comparing Amazon’s Top Kitchen Mats: Amazon’s Choice vs. Amazon Best Seller

Standing for long periods while cooking or cleaning can be exhausting—but a good kitchen mat can make a world of difference. Whether you’re an avid home chef or simply want more comfort in your kitchen space, today we’re reviewing two of the most popular kitchen mats on Amazon:

Let’s dive in and see which one fits your kitchen best!


StepRite Cushioned Anti-Fatigue Mat – Amazon’s Choice

  • Anti-Fatigue Comfort: StepRite 0.4 inch thick kitchen mat offers supportive cushioning that eases strain on your feet an…
  • Stain Resistant: Our kitchen mats have a stain-resistant texture that makes cleaning simple. Whether it’s water, wine, o…
  • Non-Slip Design: This standing mat features non-slip backing to keep it securely in place on various surfaces like tile,…
  • Reliable Material: StepRite kitchen rugs are crafted from premium material that maintains its shape and support over tim…

Key Features:

  • Dimensions: 17.3″ x 28″
  • Material: High-density PVC + memory foam
  • Slip-Resistant: Non-skid base for added safety
  • Surface: Waterproof and oil-resistant
  • Use Case: Perfect for daily kitchen standing tasks

What We Loved:

  • Comfortable underfoot without being too squishy
  • Easy to clean with just a quick wipe-down
  • Textured surface offers decent grip
  • The mat stays flat—no annoying curling at the edges

Keep in Mind:

  • Only one size available (currently)
  • May shift slightly on super-smooth flooring

DEXI Anti-Fatigue Kitchen Mat – Amazon Best Seller

  • Standard Size: 0.4 inch Thick. These red circle kitchen rugs set contains 2 rectangular mats (17.3 x 28 inches and 17.3 …
  • Anti-fatigue Mat: The comfort standing kitchen mat relieves back pain and spinal pressure, and helps to improve circulat…
  • Stylish Design: The modern geometric lines and vivid red color, match any decor nicely and make the foam mats perfect fo…
  • Kid and Pet-friendly: These red and black kitchen rugs are kid approved and pet friendly. The non-skid kitchen mats for …

Key Features:

  • Dimensions: Available in multiple sizes (17″ x 29″, 20″ x 39″, and more)
  • Material: PVC surface with high-density foam core
  • Durability: Water-resistant, stain-resistant
  • Slip Resistance: Strong non-slip bottom
  • Use Case: Ideal for home chefs or busy kitchens

What We Loved:

  • More size and color options than StepRite
  • Excellent cushioning—perfect for long meal preps
  • Anti-curl design keeps edges flush with floor
  • Surprisingly affordable for the comfort it provides

Keep in Mind:

  • Mild odor on unboxing (dissipates in a day)
  • Slightly softer feel than StepRite, which might not appeal to everyone

Side-by-Side Comparison

FeatureStepRite (Amazon’s Choice)DEXI (Best Seller)
ComfortMedium-Firm SupportPlush & Soft
Anti-Slip BaseYesYes
Water/Oil ResistanceYesYes
Design OptionsLimitedMultiple Sizes/Colors
CleaningWipe Clean SurfaceWipe Clean Surface
Price$$$
Title
Thumbnail
Kitchen Mats for Floor red Kitchen Rugs Modern Abstract Circle Anti Fatigue Kitchen Mats Waterproof Floor Mats Cushioned Non-Skid Standing Mats for Laundry, Office, Set of 2,17.3 x 28+17.3 x 47 Inch
Price
$35.99
More information
Prime Status
Title
Thumbnail
StepRite Kitchen Mats, 2PCS Kitchen Rugs, Cushioned Anti Fatigue Kitchen Mats for Floor, Non-Slip Standing Desk Mat, Waterproof Kitchen Rug Set for Kitchen, Floor, Office, 17.3"x30"+17.3"x47", Black
Price
$22.99
More information
Prime Status

Final Verdict: Which One Wins?

Both of these mats offer excellent value, comfort, and durability—but each is better suited for different preferences.

Choose StepRite if:

  • You like a firmer, more supportive mat
  • Simplicity and Amazon’s Choice badge matter to you
  • You want a minimalist design that blends in

Choose DEXI if:

  • You prefer softer, thicker padding under your feet
  • You want more size and color options
  • You’re working with a tighter budget

You can’t go wrong with either—it all depends on your kitchen style and standing habits.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top